Lived Experience Versus Gravitas

Traveler crossing a rope bridge between countryside and glowing fantasy mountains

John McWhorter, a linguist and a New York Times columnist, takes on a variety of issues—from the political to the cultural–and explores their implications. In a world where every blurb and fart seems to be analyzed, his take opens one’s eyes to how language and its use define or corral an issue. More simply, his column is worth the read.

Last week, he wrote “Should Living Be Enough ‘Lived Experience’ for a Writer?” It pulls this way and that at a concept floating around the literary scene for the past two decades, asking: should a writer pen a story, especially fiction, if he or she has not lived the experience? Under the banner of this literary critique, a white man, for example, should not write stories about Black women because he has never been a woman or African American.

The argument confuses me as a reader and a writer. Homer, Dante, Chaucer, Milton, Stephen Crane, Virginia Woolf, J.R.R. Tolkien, Tom Wolfe, and hundreds of other writers have not “lived” the experiences they wrote about. They researched, interviewed people, and imagined a world they’ve never walked in. They’ve done it honestly and empathically by releasing themselves from the bonds they normally hold as true and, nonjudgmentally, entangling themselves in the bonds of their characters.

That is not to say the “lived-experience” argument does not warn against exploiting someone’s story. For example, in 2001 Percival Everett released the novel Erasure (also a great movie), in which the author explores the world of a fiction writer pushing the boundaries of serious literature. Unfortunately, serious literature doesn’t sell well, and his agent can’t get a publisher to take on his new work. Frustrated, he writes the worst novel he can imagine. It hinges on the use of street jargon and stereotypes. The writer is disgusted by his creation, but his agent sends it out. It’s picked up. It becomes a best seller. The satire then explodes.

Everett didn’t live this life, but I have no doubt he felt the frustrations, and he used empathy to connect with his character’s many struggles. By exposing this fictional writer’s struggles, Everett mocks the lived-experience argument while also recognizing its value. In other words, it’s not an either-or issue. It’s a discussion of honesty, integrity, and responsibility to characters’ authentic voice and behavior. It’s a debate about mediocre versus great craftsmanship, exploitation versus authenticity.

The task of the serious writer is to weave oneself into characters and establish empathy with them and for their experiences. A lived experience facilitates that task, but it’s not required. The writer must get under their character’s skin, know all there is to know and feel, and in words and their euphony capture the nature of an individual who may never have existed in anyone’s lived experience. Is it easy? No and yes.

It’s not easy for the individual who believes that they can embrace empathy with thoughts off the top of their head. It is “easy” when you think of the character in their entirety. The shape of their body, the color of their hair, their musculature, their cadence of speech, their tone of speech. Eye color, their education, their work, their pleasures, their anger, their love, and how they eat, piss, and take a dump. The writer will not use all of this information, but each piece is a tool that enables the writer to live in the skin of a character, giving her/him gravitas. Afterall, the writer owes the character because he/she has created a living being for the reader, and as with all living beings, the writer must respect them even with all their foibles. When that happens, the reader feels the gravitas, making the fictional character real.

My best example occurred while reading Americafn Psycho. Long before the book was published, I had pondered the makeup of a psychotic killer, whose existence was inconsistent with everything I thought human. As I read Ellis’s work, I found a growing empathy for the main character, and my response revolted me. Yet that was precisely what Ellis set out to do, and why I started reading it. By page 50, my empathy grew stronger, and I was disgusted. I was understanding the character in a way I didn’t want to comprehend.

I never picked up the book again. Ellis took a lot of heat for the book, especially for its misogyny. I never found the book’s gore gratuitous. It was the world of a psycho. I am sure that Ellis never lived the experiences found in the book. Gravitas.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Words by Joseph Conlin

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading